The operational flight and multi-crew scheduling problem

This paper introduces a new kind of operational multi-crew scheduling problem which consists in simultaneously modifying, as necessary, the existing flight departure times and planned individual work days (duties) for the set of crew members, while respecting predefined aircraft itineraries. The splitting of a planned crew is allowed during a day of operations, where it is more important to cover a flight than to keep planned crew members together. The objective is to cover a maximum number of flights from a day of operations while minimizing changes in both the flight schedule and the next-day planned duties for the considered crew members. A new type of the same flight departure time constraints is introduced. They ensure that a flight which belongs to several personalized duties, where the number of duties is equal to the number of crew members assigned to the flight, will have the same departure time in each of these duties. Two variants of the problem are considered. The first variant allows covering of flights by less than the planned number of crew members, while the second one requires covering of flights by a complete crew. The problem is mathematically formulated as an integer nonlinear multi-commodity network flow model with time windows and supplementary constraints. The optimal solution approach is based on Dantzig-Wolfe decomposition/column generation embedded into a branch-and-bound scheme. The resulting computational times on commercial-size problems are very good. Our new simultaneous approach produces solutions whose quality is far better than that of the traditional sequential approach where the flight schedule has been changed first and then input as a fixed data to the crew scheduling problem

The positive edge pricing rule for the dual simplex

International audienceIn this article, we develop the two-dimensional positive edge criterion for the dual simplex. This work extends a similar pricing rule implemented by Towhidi et al. [24] to reduce the negative effects of degeneracy in the primal simplex. In the dual simplex, degeneracy occurs when nonbasic variables have a zero reduced cost, and it may lead to pivots that do not improve the objective value. We analyze dual degeneracy to characterize a particular set of dual compatible variables such that if any of them is selected to leave the basis the pivot will be nondegenerate. The dual positive edge rule can be used to modify any pivot selection rule so as to prioritize compatible variables. The expected effect is to reduce the number of pivots during the solution of degenerate problems with the dual simplex. For the experiments, we implement the positive edge rule within the dual simplex of the COIN-OR LP solver, and combine it with both the dual Dantzig and the dual steepest edge criteria. We test our implementation on 62 instances from four well-known benchmarks for linear programming. The results show that the dual positive edge rule significantly improves on the classical pricing rules

Two decomposition algorithms for solving a minimum weight maximum clique model for the air conflict resolution problem

International audienceIn this article, we tackle the conflict resolution problem using a new variant of the minimum-weight maximum-clique model. The problem involves identifying maneuvers that maintain the required separation distance between all pairs of a set of aircraft while minimizing fuel costs. We design a graph in which the vertices correspond to a finite set of maneuvers and the edges connect conflict-free maneuvers. A maximum clique of minimal weight yields a conflict-free situation that involves all the aircraft and minimizes the costs induced. The innovation of the model is its cost structure: the costs of the vertices cannot be determined a priori, since they depend on the vertices in the clique. We formulate the problem as a mixed integer linear program. Since the modeling of the aircraft dynamics and the computation of trajectories is separated from the solution process, the model is flexible. As a consequence, our mathematical framework is valid for any hypotheses. In particular, the aircraft can perform dynamic velocity, heading, and flight-level changes. To solve instances involving a large number of aircraft spread over several flight levels, we introduce two decomposition algorithms. The first is a sequential mixed integer linear optimization procedure that iteratively refines the discretization of the maneuvers to yield a trade-off between computational time and cost. The second is a large neighborhood search heuristic that uses the first procedure as a subroutine. The best solutions for the available set of maneuvers are obtained in less than 10 seconds for instances with up to 250 aircraft randomly allocated to 20 flight levels

Improved Primal Simplex: A More General Theoretical Framework and an Extended Experimental Analysis

International audienceIn this article, we propose a general framework for an algorithm derived from the primal simplex that guarantees a strict improvement in the objective after each iteration. Our approach relies on the identification of compatible variables that ensure a nondegenerate iteration if pivoted into the basis. The problem of finding a strict improvement in the objective function is proved to be equivalent to two smaller problems respectively focusing on compatible and incompatible variables. We then show that the improved primal simplex (IPS) of Elhallaoui et al. is a particular implementation of this generic theoretical framework. The resulting new description of IPS naturally emphasizes what should be considered as necessary adaptations of the framework versus specific implementation choices. This provides original insight into IPS that allows for the identification of weaknesses and potential alternative choices that would extend the efficiency of the method to a wider set of problems. We perform experimental tests on an extended collection of data sets including instances of Mittelmann's benchmark for linear programming. The results confirm the excellent potential of IPS and highlight some of its limits while showing a path toward an improved implementation of the generic algorithm

Machine learning in airline crew pairing to construct initial clusters for dynamic constraint aggregation

The crew pairing problem (CPP) is generally modelled as a set partitioning problem where the flights have to be partitioned in pairings. A pairing is a sequence of flight legs separated by connection time and rest periods that starts and ends at the same base. Because of the extensive list of complex rules and regulations, determining whether a sequence of flights constitutes a feasible pairing can be quite difficult by itself, making CPP one of the hardest of the airline planning problems. In this paper, we first propose to improve the prototype Baseline solver of Desaulniers et al. (2020)2020) by adding dynamic control strategies to obtain an efficient solver for large-scale CPPs: Commercial-GENCOL-DCA. These solvers are designed to aggregate the flights covering constraints to reduce the size of the problem. Then, we use machine learning (ML) to produce clusters of flights having a high probability of being performed consecutively by the same crew. The solver combines several advanced Operations Research techniques to assemble and modify these clusters, when necessary, to produce a good solution. We show, on monthly CPPs with up to 50 000 flights, that Commercial-GENCOL-DCA with clusters produced by ML-based heuristics outperforms Baseline fed by initial clusters that are pairings of a solution obtained by rolling horizon with GENCOL. The reduction of solution cost averages between 6.8% and 8.52%, which is mainly due to the reduction in the cost of global constraints between 69.79% and 78.11%

Étude bibliographique de l'ordonnancement simultané des moyens de production et des ressources humaines

RÉSUMÉ: Alors que de très nombreuses recherches portent sur l'ordonnancement d'atelier, bien peu portent sur l'ordonnancement des ressources humaines et encore moins sur l'ordonnancement simultané des ordres de production et des opérateurs. Si quelques travaux existent sur l'ordonnancement des ressources humaines en vue d'ajuster la capacité à la charge ou sur la définition fine du cycle de travail sur un poste, les manques sont flagrants au niveau de l'ordonnancement. Ce travail met l'accent sur les nombreux manques dans ce domaine

The daily tail assignment problem under operational uncertainty using look-ahead maintenance constraints

Abstract The tail assignment problem is a critical part of the airline planning process that assigns specific aircraft to sequences of flights, called lines-of-flight, to satisfy operational constraints. The aim of this paper is to develop an operationally flexible method, based upon the one-day routes business model, to compute tail assignments that satisfy short-range—within the next three days—aircraft maintenance requirements. While maintenance plans commonly span multiple days, the methods used to compute tail assignments for the given plans can be overly complex and provide little recourse in the event of schedule perturbations. The presented approach addresses operational uncertainty by using solutions from the one-day routes aircraft maintenance routing approach as input. The daily tail assignment problem is solved with an objective to satisfy maintenance requirements explicitly for the current day and implicitly for the subsequent two days. A computational study will be performed to assess the performance of exact and heuristic solution algorithms that modify the input lines-of-flight to reduce maintenance misalignments. The daily tail assignment problem and the developed algorithms are demonstrated to compute solutions that effectively satisfy maintenance requirements when evaluated using input data collected from three different airlines

VRP with Time Windows

Abstract This paper presents a survey of the research on the Vehicle Routing Problem with Time Windows (VRPTW), an extension of the Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem. In the VRPTW, the service at each customer must start within an associated time window and the vehicle must remain at the customer location during service. Soft time windows can be violated at a cost while hard time windows do not allow for a vehicle to arrive at a customer after the latest time to begin service. We first present a multi-commodity network flow formulation with time and capacity constraints for the VRPTW. Approximation methods proposed in the literature to derive upper bounds are then reviewed. Then we explain how lower bounds can be obtained using optimal approaches, namely, Lagrangean relaxation and column generation. Next, we provide branching and cutting strategies that can be embedded within these optimal approaches to produce integer solutions. Special cases and extensions to the VRPTW follow as well as our conclusions. Résumé Cet article synthèse porte sur les récents développements concernant le problème du routage de véhicules sous des contraintes de fenêtres de temps. Dans ce problème, le serviceà un client doit débuterà l'intérieur d'un intervalle de temps. Celui-ci peutêtre, soit relaché au prix d'une certaine pénalité, soit rigide, auquel cas, il n'est pas permis de dépasser la limite supérieure. Nous présentons un modèle de réseau multi-flots avec des contraintes de temps et de capacité. Les méthodes heuristiques permettant de calculer des bornes supérieures sont d'abord présentées. Suivent les modèles d'optimisation basés sur la relaxation lagrangienne et la génération de colonnes pourévaluer des bornes inférieures. Enfin, on présente les stratégies de coupes et de branchements liéesà ces méthodes afin de déterminer des solutions entières. L'article se termine par l'étude de cas particuliers et d'extensions ainsi que nos conclusions